A water softener and water heater are shown in this image. The water softener is removing hard water minerals from the water, which will help to improve the performance of the water heater and the quality of the water.

How a Water Softener Can Affect Your Water Heater

If you live in an area with hard water, you may be wondering whether installing a water softener could help extend the life and efficiency of your water heater. Hard water contains high levels of calcium and magnesium ions that can lead to limescale buildup and corrosion inside water heaters and pipes. The scale buildup reduces heating efficiency, while corrosion can cause leaks and shorten the lifespan of your water heater.

A water softener removes the calcium and magnesium ions through a process called ion exchange. This converts the hard minerals into sodium ions, effectively softening the water flowing into your home’s plumbing. But how exactly does soft water impact your water heater?

In this guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about using a water softener with a water heater, including:

  • The benefits of softened water for water heaters
  • Potential drawbacks to be aware of
  • Water softener installation and maintenance tips
  • How to choose the right type and size of softener
  • And much more to help you make an informed decision

How Does a Water Softener Help Extend the Life of a Water Heater?

The primary benefit of using a water softener with your water heater is reduced limescale buildup and corrosion. Hard water minerals bind together and attach to the interior of pipes, the tank walls, and heating elements. As this scale accumulates over time, it:

  • Reduces heating efficiency: The scale acts as an insulation barrier that inhibits heat transfer. This means your water heater has to work harder to heat the water.
  • Shortens the life of the unit: Scale buildup puts added strain on the components, eventually leading to part failures. Corrosion caused by hard water also damages the tank and pipes.
  • Increases energy bills: With lower efficiency, your water heater has to run longer to heat water, driving up energy costs.

A water softener prevents these problems by capturing the calcium and magnesium before they can bind together and form scale deposits. By keeping the interior of your water heater scale-free, softened water allows the unit to run more efficiently and last longer.

Additional Benefits of Using Softened Water

Installing a water softener provides additional advantages beyond just protecting your water heater:

  • Improves efficiency of all water-using appliances: Scale buildup affects all appliances that use hot water, like dishwashers and washing machines. Soft water keeps them running efficiently as well.
  • Removes soap scum: Hard water causes soap scum to form on sinks, showers, and bathtubs. Soft water allows soap to lather properly and rinse cleanly.
  • Leaves laundry cleaner and brighter: Without hard minerals binding to fabric, laundry rinses cleaner and looks brighter.
  • Leaves skin and hair feeling smoother: The minerals in hard water can dry out skin and hair. Soft water makes bathing and showering more pleasant.
  • Fewer spotty dishes: Dishes and glassware come out of the dishwasher cleaner without spotting and film caused by hard water.

Essentially, softening your entire home’s water supply provides wide-ranging benefits beyond just your water heater.

Potential Drawbacks of Using a Water Softener

While water softeners provide many benefits, there are also some potential drawbacks to be aware of:

  • Increased cost: Purchasing and installing a water softener costs $500 to $2,500 upfront, plus added monthly costs for salt, maintenance, and electricity to run the unit.
  • More frequent anode rod replacement: The anode rod protects the interior of your water heater from corrosion. With soft water, the rod corrodes faster and needs replacing more often.
  • Proper adjustment required: If your softener is set too high, the water can become overly corrosive. Improper settings can damage your water heater and plumbing.
  • Ongoing maintenance: Water softeners require regular maintenance like checking salt levels, periodically replacing filter media, and cleaning the resin tank.
  • Potential for salt bridge buildup: A salt bridge can form when salt hardens into a solid chunk. This can block the flow of brine needed for softening.

With the proper sizing, settings, and maintenance, these risks can be minimized. We’ll provide tips later in this article on how to choose and maintain your softener to avoid potential downsides.

How Much Does It Cost to Install a Water Softener?

If you decide to install a water softener to maximize your water heater’s efficiency and longevity, what should you expect to budget for it? Here are the main costs involved:

  • Equipment purchase: The softener unit itself ranges from $500 for simple manual models to $2,000 or more for large metered systems with digital controls. On average, expect to pay $1,100 to $1,500.
  • Professional installation: Plumbing in a softener system runs $200 to $500 depending on complexity. DIY installation is possible but involves shutting off your main water supply.
  • Extra connections and parts: Items like bypass valves, unions, and additional tubing cost around $50 to $100. Upgrading to flexible stainless steel lines is optimal to prevent bursting from water hammer.
  • Salt for regeneration: Ongoing salt costs average $5 to $15 per month depending on water hardness and household size. Potassium chloride is a salt-free alternative if on a sodium-restricted diet.

In total, budget $1,000 to $2,500 for purchasing and installing a quality water softener suited for your home, plus several hundred dollars annually for operation and maintenance. View this as an investment in the longevity of your water heater and plumbing, which saves substantially on repairs and replacements down the road.

What Type of Water Softener is Best for Your Water Heater?

Once you decide to soften your water supply to protect your water heater, the next question becomes: what type is best? Here is an overview of the two main options:

Salt-based (ion exchange) softeners

These are the most common and effective systems, especially for very hard water. They use an ion exchange resin bed that swaps hardness minerals for sodium ions, reducing water hardness.


  • Remove almost all trace hardness minerals (up to 99%)
  • Best for very hard water areas
  • Fully automatic operation


  • Require regular addition of salt
  • Produce salty waste water during regeneration

Salt-free softeners

Salt-free systems use filtration media like activated carbon to attract and bind hardness minerals through a process called nucleation assisted crystallization.


  • No salt use
  • Less wastewater produced
  • May lower sodium intake


  • Not as effective for very hard water
  • Media requires more frequent replacement
  • Tank size may need to be larger

Salt-free softeners are good for moderately hard water around 1-10 grains per gallon. For hardness above 15-20 grains per gallon, a salt-based ion exchange softener is recommended to provide the highest efficiency.

Be sure to test your water’s hardness and consult with a water treatment professional when choosing the best type of softener for your needs. They can help you balance effectiveness against operating costs.

water score banner 2

Tips for Maintaining Your Water Softener

Once your water softener is installed, be sure to perform regular maintenance. This keeps it working properly to protect your water heater and plumbing. Here are important maintenance tips:

  • Check the salt level monthly: Refill the brine tank as needed to ensure continuous softening capability. Letting it run out of salt allows hard water to flow through.
  • Periodically clean the resin tank: Every 6-12 months, sanitize the resin bed with cleaners to prevent bacteria growth and remove sediment.
  • Test water hardness: Use test strips monthly to ensure your softener is removing hardness properly. Adjust settings if needed.
  • Replace the anode rod more frequently: Softened water corrodes the anode rod faster, so replace it every 2-3 years instead of the typical 4-6 years. Use magnesium or aluminum anode rods which corrode slower than zinc rods with softened water.
  • Watch for salt bridging: Break up any hardened salt that could block the brine line and prevent proper softening.

With regular maintenance, your water softener and water heater will operate optimally together for years of reliable service.

How Do You Know When to Replace an Old Water Softener?

If you inherit an older water softener in a home purchase or your system is over 10 years old, how do you know when it needs replacing? Here are signs it’s time for a new water softener:

  • Water tests show hardness: If tests indicate the water is no longer being softened, the resin beads are exhausted and can’t be regenerated.
  • Salt use has increased: A system using much more salt than it used to could indicate issues with valve operation and incomplete regeneration cycles.
  • Components are corroded/leaking: Severe corrosion of the salt tank, resin tank, or control valve indicate an aging, inefficient system.
  • Softener doesn’t regenerate: If you can no longer hear the softener running through regeneration cycles overnight, the control valve likely needs repair or replacement.
  • Water pressure loss: Flow restrictions in and out of the softener can signify compacted resin beads or clogged pipes.
  • Salt bridges keep forming: Constant salt bridging no matter what you try may mean it’s time to replace softener components.

Ideally, water softeners last 10-15 years when properly maintained. At the first major signs of operation issues, replacement is likely the best option for optimal water heater protection. Newer models are much more efficient and use less salt and water during regeneration.

Choosing the Right Size Water Softener

Choosing an adequately sized water softener ensures optimal performance. Undersized units can’t fully soften your household’s water. Oversized systems are inefficient and waste salt and water. Follow these tips to get the right size:

  • Calculate daily water use: Estimate total gallons used per day based on family size, appliances, showers, etc.
  • Determine water hardness: Have your water tested to measure hardness in grains per gallon (gpg).
  • Size the system capacity: Use the capacity sizing chart based on water hardness and daily use. Add a bit extra capacity as a buffer.
  • Consider peak flow rates: Account for periods of heavy water use to ensure adequate softening flow.
  • Leave room for expansion: If expanding your home or family, size up for expected increased water use.

A water treatment professional can help determine the ideal softener specifications for your home’s needs. Investing in a properly sized system means optimizing performance and efficiency.

Installing a Water Softener: Location Tips

Where you install your water softener can impact performance and convenience. Here are tips on the best locations:

  • Install near water supply lines: Place the softener close to the main water supply lines entering your home for simpler plumbing connections.
  • Choose an easily accessible spot: Pick an installation spot where you can easily access the unit for salt filling and maintenance.
  • Consider basement or garage: A basement or attached garage provides protection from freezing. Leave room for salt bags.
  • Keep it out of sunlight: Ultraviolet light can degrade plastic components. Avoid exterior walls or windows.
  • Make it the last treatment: Install softeners after any existing water filters so filtered water gets softened.
  • Leave electrical access: You’ll need an electrical outlet nearby for the control valve and transformer.

Taking the time to carefully select the installation location will keep your softener performing optimally as it conditions all the water entering your home and water heater.

Getting the Most From Your Water Softener Investment

If you live in a hard water area, installing a water softener can be one of the best ways to maximize the lifespan and efficiency of your water heater while avoiding costly scale buildup and corrosion damage.

Take the time to choose the right type of softener for your home’s water hardness level. Properly size the system for your household needs. And perform regular maintenance like checking salt levels and sanitizing the resin bed. This ensures your investment continues providing optimized results.

By softening your water supply, you can minimize expensive repairs and replacements of your water heater and plumbing. You’ll also enjoy the benefits of soap and detergent working better, brighter laundry, smoother-feeling skin and hair, and spot-free dishes.

If you have any other questions about using a water softener with your household water heater, contact a qualified plumber or water treatment specialist. They can advise you on the best options for your particular home.


Does a water softener really help extend the life of a water heater?

Yes, by reducing limescale buildup and corrosion, a water softener can significantly extend the lifespan of a water heater. The scale that forms from hard water causes added strain on components and reduces heating efficiency. Softened water prevents scale deposits and damage from corrosion.

What is the maintenance required for a water softener?

To keep a water softener working properly, it’s important to periodically check the salt levels and refill the brine tank as needed. The resin tank should be cleaned and sanitized every 6-12 months to remove sediment and prevent bacteria growth. Test water hardness monthly and adjust settings if needed.

How often should the anode rod be replaced with a water softener?

With softened water, the anode rod corrodes faster and should be replaced every 2-3 years compared to the typical 4-6 years with hard water. Using a magnesium or aluminum anode rod also slows the corrosion rate.

What are signs that an old water softener needs to be replaced?

Signs include the system no longer softening water, using much more salt than it used to, leaking or corroded components, failure to regenerate properly, loss of water pressure, and persistent salt bridging issues. Replacement is usually needed after 10-15 years.

Should you install a water softener before or after other water filters?

Water softeners should be installed after other water filters. This allows filtered water to then be softened as it enters your home’s plumbing and water heater. The filters remove sediment and particles first.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *